Enforcing the "Commitments" Made in Impact Statements: A Proposed Passage Through a Thicket of Case Law
A series of recent judicial decisions under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)1 sheds light on an issue that has evaded serious scrutiny for the better part of the statute's existence: can the representations made within an environmental impact statement (EIS) be enforced? Stated differently, when a federal agency fails either to construct a project as "promised" within the EIS or to contain adverse environmental impacts within the prescribed levels, may injured parties obtain relief in federal court?