A settling CAA defendant that violated its Title V operating permit at a secondary lead smelting facility in Muncie, Indiana, must pay civil penalties to the United States and Indiana, must grant the United States and Indiana equivalent allowed penalty claims in a bankruptcy proceeding totaling $820,000, and must make specific improvements to its air pollution control and monitoring systems at the Muncie facility.

Settling APA and CWA plaintiffs that challenged an Administrative Order for Compliance that was issued for discharging pollutants into waters of the United States without a permit must pay a civil penalty and must perform mitigation.