Scaling the Garbage Mountain: New Jersey Supreme Court Upholds Prohibition on Solid Waste Importation

May 1976
Citation:
6
ELR 10105
Issue
5

In a decision that is likely to be emulated in other states, the Supreme Court of New Jersey has recently rejected Commerce Clause challenges to that state's ban on the in-state dumping of solid waste originating outside New Jersey. The unanimous opinion in Hackensack Meadowlands Development Commission v. Municipal Sanitary Landfill Authority1 found that state erection of such barriers was an undeniably legitimate police power action, and that the beneficial postponement of sacrificing increasingly scarce wetlands to landfill operators far outweighed any corresponding hindrance to interstate transportation of non-recyclable solid wastes. Following in the wake of notably unsuccessful attempts under the Commerce Clause to overturn bans on nonreturnable bottles,2 phosphate detergents,3 and marine oil spillage,4 the decision may ultimately lead to enactment of similar measures in other states,5 a development that would only accelerate the balkanization of environmental management. On the other hand, the case serves as a bellwhether for the tough solid waste-related land-use decisions that may soon become the national norm.

You must be an ELR-The Environmental Law Reporter subscriber to download the full article.

You are not logged in. To access this content:

Scaling the Garbage Mountain: New Jersey Supreme Court Upholds Prohibition on Solid Waste Importation

SKU: article-25154 Price: $50.00