A Response to “Rediscovering the Limitsˮ of OMB Regulatory Review

May 1987
Citation:
17
ELR 10142
Issue
5
Author
Robert E. Steinberg

Since President Reagan issued Executive Order 122911 establishing his system to review rulemaking actions by executive agencies, environmental and other public interest groups have sought to preclude the President and his delegatee, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), from reviewing or influencing agency decision-making. These groups believe that agencies will provide stronger protection for health, safety, and environmental values if freed from the disciplines of the regulatory review process which require that the agencies, to the extent permitted by their enabling legislation, promulgate regulations whose potential benefits outweigh their costs.

Robert V. Percival, in a recent Article in this journal,2 has argued that litigation can be a useful tool for limiting the regulatory review process. Citing Judge Flannery's decision in Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) v. Thomas,3 Mr. Percival argues that in those cases in which the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) or another agency has missed or is about to miss a statutory deadline, "no additional time can be allowed for OMB review."4 Apparently, Mr. Percival would urge public interest groups to bring lawsuits precluding OMB review in the many circumstances in which an agency has not met, or is not likely to meet, the statutory deadline set by Congress.

Mr. Steinberg is an attorney with the law firm of Porter, Wright, Morris & Arthur in Washington, D.C. He was Special Litigation Counsel at the United States Department of Justice from 1984 to 1986 and Special Assistant to Attorney General William French Smith from 1983 to 1984. The author was lead counsel for the government in Environmental Defense Fund v. Thomas. The views expressed in this Dialogue, however, are solely those of the author.

You must be an ELR-The Environmental Law Reporter subscriber to download the full article.

You are not logged in. To access this content:

A Response to “Rediscovering the Limitsˮ of OMB Regulatory Review

SKU: article-25623 Price: $50.00