Public Nuisance and Public Plaintiffs: Rediscovering the Common Law (Part I)

October 1986
Citation:
16
ELR 10292
Issue
10
Author
Louise A. Halper

Editors' Summary: Much attention has been focused on the role of statutes in environmental enforcement. This focus is understandable, given the huge arsenal of environmental statutes that have been enacted. But the courts have not forgotten the common law, and as this article points out, neither should litigants. Approaching the subject from the perspective of the state enforcement official, the article discusses the applicability of the common law concept of public nuisance to modern-day environmental problems, particularly those caused by hazardous waste and toxic substances. The author argues that in many situations, the public nuisance doctrine provides enforcement officials with powerful flexibility not otherwise available. In this first of three parts, the author sets the stage for an appropriate understanding of the modern potential of public nuisance by discussing the history of public nuisance, analyzing the doctrine's original purposes, and examining how the concept has changed over the years. A second article will look at remedies available to the state litigator and possible defenses that may be raised.

Louise A. Halper is an Assistant Attorney General in the Environmental Protection Bureau, New York State Department of Law and a member of the New York and New Jersey bars. The views set forth in this article are the author's and are not necessarily those of the Department of Law or Attorney General Robert Abrams.

Article File