Overcoming Aesthetic Restrictions on Residential Solar Collectors: A Guidebook for Lawyers and Homeowners

June 1981
Citation:
11
ELR 50019
Issue
6
Author
Elizabeth Entwistle, Frank Meeker, and Janet Nakamori

The harnessing of the sun's direct energy to heat and cool homes and to heat water for household uses is changing residential architecture across America. As the use of conventional fuels is reduced globally, residential solar systems will become a common sight in the 1980s and beyond. Today, there is a large variety of residential solar designs because the technology is young, decentralized, and rapidly growing and because there is much diversity in climates, latitudes, and architectural styles in the regions where the technology is applied. Each solar design has a unique visual impact. With rational and imaginative planning, communities can in most cases balance the land-use equities of solar homeowners and their neighbors so as to achieve cost-effective solar designs that meet the aesthetic and architectural standards of the community.

Several communities have pioneered in the development of aesthetic guidelines for residential solar designs. Their experience is a natural starting point for any individual or community planning group involved in solar land-use issues.1 The American Planning Association (APA) has also done ground-breaking work in its recent manual, Residential Solar Design Review, prepared for the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).2 That manual suggests ways to modify both solar designs and conventional design restrictions to overcome aesthetic barriers. It is very useful for establishing objective standards of architectural "reasonableness" for a community's solar designs.

Elizabeth Entwisle (A.B. 1974, Wellesley College; J.D. 1977, University of Pittsburgh) is a part-time staff attorney at the Environmental Law Institute and is also in private practice. She was project manager for this article under the Institute's Energy Program. Frank Meeker (B.S.E.E. 1964, Stanford University; J.D. 1969, University of Washington) was acting director of the Energy Program when the project began and later became a consultant to it. Janet Nakamori (B.A. 1977, University of Hawaii; J.D. 1981, Georgetown University) was a legal research assistant in the Energy Program and developed the article's case studies. She is currently working in the law firm of Rogovin, Stern, Huge & Lenzner in Washington, D.C. The article was developed from a guidebook written under Grant H-8213 RG from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. The authors thank David Engel, Director of Market Development in HUD's Residential Solar Demonstration Program and government technical representative for this grant, and Robert M. Entwisle Jr., a lawyer in private practice in Pittsburgh, for their invaluable help on the project.

Article File