California Need Not Go Nuclear: The Supreme Court Holds That California's Moratorium on New Nuclear Plans Is Not Preempted by Federal Law

July 1983
Citation:
13
ELR 10216
Issue
7
Author
A. Dan Tarlock

Editors' Summary: In the 1982 Term, the Supreme Court decided three cases involving the nuclear power industry. In the first and third cases, the Court continued its pattern of deference to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) and nuclear energy. But to the surprise of many observers, in the second case, Pacific Gas & Electric Co. v. State Energy Conservation and Development Commission, the Court unanimously held that the Atomic Energy Act (AEA) does not preempt a California statute imposing a moratorium on new nuclear plant construction until the federal government approves a technology for disposing of nuclear wastes. Although approving the ultimate ruling, Professor Tarlock criticizes the Court for its failure to provide useful guidance on the law of preemption. The Court found that the state law was founded on economic and not safety concerns and was therefore not preempted by the AEA, which vests exclusive control over nuclear safety with the NRC. Because of the Court's distinction, Professor Tarlock points out, the question of preemption turns on fictitious legislative drafting leaving open the possibility that other states' statutes may not fare so well. However, he concludes that the Court was justified in defining the conflict between federal and state regulation narrowly and refusing to continue to defer blindly to the agency.

Mr. Tarlock teaches law at Chicago Kent College of Law in the Illinois Institute of Technology. He is a coauthor of a forthcoming environmental law casebook with Prof. Frederick R. Anderson of the University of Utah, and former president of ELI, and Prof. Daniel R. Mandelker of Washington University.

You must be an ELR-The Environmental Law Reporter subscriber to download the full article.

You are not logged in. To access this content:

California Need Not Go Nuclear: The Supreme Court Holds That California's Moratorium on New Nuclear Plans Is Not Preempted by Federal Law

SKU: article-25446 Price: $50.00